00:00
Think about a decision you made recently. Itdoesn't have to be something important.
Maybe you decided to call someone. Maybe youbought something you didn't really need.
Maybe you stayed silent when you wanted to saysomething. You considered your options.
You made a decision. And as far as you wereconcerned, it was your choice. But let me
ask you something. Why did you choose thatparticular option? Was it because you carefully
thought it through? Because it felt right? Becauseyou were afraid of what might happen
if you chose differently? And where did thatfeeling come from? Imagine that you could go
back to the exact moment before you made thedecision. You could see every thought that
passed through your mind, every memory thatinfluenced you, every fear you didn't quite
recognize. Would you still make the same choice?We like to believe that our decisions begin
with us. That we look at the world, weigh thepossibilities, and decide what to do.
But perhaps the process begins much earlier. Longbefore we consciously make a choice,
we have already been shaped by experiences,expectations, habits, and things other people
have taught us to believe. So here's the question.When you finally say,
I chose this, how much of that choice was reallyyours?
Consider two people offered exactly the sameopportunity. One accepts immediately. The other
refuses. From the outside, it looks simple. Twopeople, two different choices. But one person
grew up believing that taking risks was how youmoved forward. The other learned that risks were
dangerous, that one mistake could cost youeverything. Neither person necessarily thinks
about those lessons when making the decision. Theymay simply say, it felt right, or something
told me not to do it. And they may be completelysincere. Our past doesn't always appear as a
memory we can clearly identify. Sometimes itappears as a preference, an instinct, a sudden
feeling of discomfort that seems to come fromnowhere. The same thing happens with our habits.
You might believe you chose a familiar routinebecause it suits you. But have you ever wondered
whether you keep choosing it because it's whatyou've always done? And what about the opinions
you hold? How many did you examine carefullybefore accepting them? How many came from people
you trusted, environments you grew up in, or ideasyou heard so often that they eventually felt like
your own? None of this means your decisions aremeaningless. Influence is not the same as control.
But it does raise an uncomfortable possibility.Something can influence your choice without
your ever noticing that it's there. And if youcannot see the influence, how can you know how
much it mattered? Here's where the questionbecomes more difficult. Suppose you make a
decision and
feel completely certain that you chose freely.Does that feeling prove that you did? We often
explain our decisions after we've made them. Wefind reasons that make sense. We build a story
03:04
about why we acted the way we did. Sometimes thosereasons are accurate. Sometimes we may be giving a
clear explanation to a decision that was shaped byinfluences we barely understand. Think about the
last time someone asked you, why did you do that?Did you immediately know the answer? Or did you
have to search for one? Now imagine a moretroubling situation. You reject an opportunity
because something about it feels wrong. Monthslater, you discover that your decision was
influenced
by a fear you had never acknowledged. Would yousay you made the wrong choice? Or would you say
you
finally understand the choice you made? And ifunderstanding your own motives changes how you
see that decision, does it also change how you seeyourself? We want to believe that we're the
authors
of our lives. Not just people reacting tocircumstances, repeating old patterns, or
following
paths that were laid out long before we noticedthem. Perhaps freedom doesn't mean making
decisions
without any influence at all. That might beimpossible. Perhaps it means becoming more aware
of those influences, questioning them, anddeciding which ones deserve to guide us. But even
then,
another question remains. If your values, yourdoubts, and your desire to change have all been
shaped by your experiences, where does yourfreedom begin? Maybe the answer isn't as simple
as we want it to be. Perhaps a choice can beinfluenced by the past and still belong to us.
You didn't choose every experience that shapedyou. You didn't choose every fear you learned,
every belief you inherited, or every habit youdeveloped. But you can sometimes stop and examine
them. You can ask yourself why a particulardecision feels inevitable. You can notice when
fear is speaking louder than reason. You canreconsider a belief you've carried for years
without ever questioning it. And sometimes, youcan choose differently. Not because you have
escaped
every influence, but because you've become awareof one that used to operate unnoticed.
That may not be complete freedom, but perhaps itis a meaningful kind of freedom.
So think again about the decision you rememberedat the beginning, the one you made recently.
Would you make the same choice today if youunderstood everything that influenced you?
And if your answer is yes, does that make it moretruly yours? Or is a decision yours
simply because you are the person who made it,regardless of everything that led you there?
We make choices every day. Most of them passwithout a second thought. But every now and then,
it's worth stopping to ask what really happened inthe moment we decided. Because the most difficult
question may not be whether you had a choice. Itmay be whether you understand the person who made
06:00
it. I'm Jonah Whitmore, and I'll leave you withone question. Did you really choose,
or did you simply follow the influences you neverlearned to see?
